PlayNook

Board Game · Blocking Game

Play Pong Hau K'i Online — Free, and Solved

Five points, four pieces, and never more than two moves to choose from. Slide into the gap; if you cannot move, you lose. The whole game is one shape you must never enter.

Five points, four pieces, and never more than two moves to choose from. Slide one of yours into the empty point; if you cannot move, you lose.

It is about as small as a board game can be while still being a game — small enough that the whole of it fits on this page.

  • 60 positions in the entire game
  • 4 of them lose — and all four are the same shape
  • 97.8 % — how often knowing that shape wins
  • 0 % — how often you lose once you know it

How do you play Pong Hau K'i?

  1. The board is five points — four corners and a centre, joined by seven lines.
  2. The centre joins all four corners. The corners join round the outside, except the top two, which are not joined to each other.
  3. Red starts on the top-left and bottom-right, blue on the top-right and bottom-left. The centre is empty.
  4. Slide one of your pieces along a line into the empty point. There is only ever one gap, so you have at most two choices.
  5. Nothing is captured and nothing is placed. The four pieces stay put all game.
  6. If you cannot move, you lose.

The whole game, on one page

Sixty positions exist. Not sixty thousand — sixty. So instead of describing the game, here it is.

Grid of all sixty positions of Pong Hau K'i, coloured by result: 4 are lost for the side to move, 8 are won, and 48 are drawn.
Every position, evaluated completely. Four squares out of sixty are the entire danger.

Forty-eight of the sixty are drawn. That is the endless shuffle: two players pushing pieces back and forth with nothing to decide.

What is the one losing shape?

All four lost positions are the same picture, and it is worth learning by eye:

That is the whole of the game's danger. There is no second trap, no variation on it, no deeper level.

Is it worth playing if it is a draw?

That depends entirely on whether the other person knows the shape.

Bar chart of how often a game of Pong Hau K'i is decided: 99.9 per cent when neither player knows the losing shape, 97.8 per cent when one knows and wins, and never when both know.
200,000 games of each, played from the standard opening.

Between two players who do not know it, somebody loses after about 28 half-moves — it feels like a real contest, and the loser never quite sees what happened. Once one side knows it, that side wins 97.8 % of games. Once both know it, every game is drawn.

So the game has an unusually short life: it is genuinely fun exactly once, and then it is solved for you personally. That is not a criticism — it is what a five-point game is for, and it is why it turns up as a children's game across half of Asia.

How do you actually win?

You cannot force a win against someone who knows the shape. What you can do — and what wins 97.8 % of games against someone who does not — is two things.

Never move into the shape. Before each move, look at where the gap will be after it. If the gap ends up on a top corner and your two pieces are the other top corner and the far bottom corner, do not make that move. There is always another one available, because a lost position can only be entered voluntarily.

Then wait. You are not building anything; there is nothing to build. You are simply staying safe while the other person has two choices every turn and no idea which is which. Sooner or later they take the wrong one — and the measurement says a game decided this way runs about 38 half-moves, so roughly nineteen turns each before the mistake arrives.

The strong computer level here does exactly this, and nothing more. It holds the solved values, it never enters a losing position, and it waits.

What the game is actually teaching

There is a reason this board turns up in classrooms as often as in playgrounds. With sixty positions it is one of the few real games a person can hold entirely in their head — you can genuinely know it, not merely play it well.

That makes it a demonstration of something bigger: what "solved" means. Chess and Go are not solved because they are too large; Pong Hau K'i is solved because it is not. The difference is only size, and the board shows you exactly what sits on the other side of that line.

Why are the top corners not joined?

Because that missing line is the game.

Join them and every corner would have three ways out. No arrangement of four pieces could ever block anybody, every position would be drawn, and there would be nothing to play. One absent edge is the difference between a game and a fidget.

Where does it come from?

Pong Hau K'i is Chinese. In Korea the same game is umul gonu — the well game, named for the shape of the board — or gang gonu. It is played in Thailand as sua tok tong and in India under other names again.

Games this small travel easily and get reinvented constantly, because the whole apparatus is five dots and four pebbles. The interesting thing is not that it spread, but that the same asymmetric board spread with it: somebody, somewhere, worked out that the missing edge was the point, and that detail survived every retelling.

Playing a friend online

Pick With a friend online under the board and press Open a table. You get a four-character code; send it to whoever you are playing. No account, no download.

If neither of you blunders, the game is drawn after the same position comes up three times — the same rule chess uses, and here it is not a formality but a necessity: without it, two careful players would never stop.

Other small games here

Shisima from Kenya and Achi from Ghana are the same order of size and rather more forgiving. Three Men's Morris is what happens when you allow nine points instead of five — and it turns out to be won for whoever starts, unless you ban the centre.

Frequently asked questions

+ How do you play Pong Hau K'i?

The board has five points: four corners and a centre, joined by seven lines. The centre joins all four corners, and the corners join round the outside except the top two, which are not joined to each other. Red starts on the top-left and bottom-right, blue on the top-right and bottom-left, and the centre is empty. On your turn you slide one of your pieces along a line into the empty point. Nothing is captured. If you cannot move, you lose.

+ Who wins Pong Hau K'i?

Neither, if both players know what they are doing. We solved the game completely: of its sixty positions, forty-eight are drawn, eight are won and four are lost. The opening position is a draw, and two competent players will shuffle for ever.

+ So how does anybody ever lose?

By walking into the one losing shape. All four lost positions are the same picture: the empty point is a top corner, and the player to move holds the other top corner together with the bottom corner diagonally across from it. Neither of their pieces touches the gap, so neither can move. You can only get there by choosing to.

+ Is it worth playing if it is a draw?

That depends entirely on whether your opponent knows the shape. We measured 200,000 games: when neither side knows it, someone loses after about 28 half-moves. When one side knows it, that side wins 97.8 % of the time. When both know it, every game is drawn. The whole game is one piece of knowledge.

+ Why are the two top corners not joined?

Because that missing line is the game. Join them and every corner would have three ways out, the trap would not exist, and nobody could ever be blocked. One absent edge is the difference between a game and an endless shuffle.

+ What else is it called?

In Korea it is umul gonu or gang gonu — the well game. It is played in Thailand as sua tok tong and in India under other names. The board turns up wherever people scratch games into the ground, because it takes five dots and two lines.

+ How do the two computer levels differ?

Easy moves at random and will walk into the trap. Hard holds the solved values and never enters a losing position, so it cannot be beaten — but it will punish you the moment you step wrong.

+ Can I play a friend online?

Yes. Choose 'With a friend online', press Open a table and send the four-character code. No account and no sign-up.

+ Is it free?

Yes, free and with no sign-up. Nothing is saved; close the tab and start again.

More games like this

Shisima — screenshot of the browser gameBoard Game
Three in a Row2 Players

Shisima

Slide three water insects around a Kenyan pond and line them up through the centre. A game takes a minute; winning takes longer.

  • Play a friend online — share a code and chat
  • Three computer difficulty levels
  • Fast one-minute games
Play Shisima
Three Men's Morris — screenshot of the browser gameBoard Game
Mill Game2 Players

Three Men's Morris

Three men each on a noughts-and-crosses grid. Nothing is ever captured — three in a row simply wins, and when the board fills you start sliding.

  • No capturing at all: three in a row ends the game
  • The centre is closed on move one — we solved the board to find out why
  • Play a friend online — share a code and chat
Play Three Men's Morris
Achi — screenshot of the browser gameBoard Game
Three in a Row2 Players

Achi

Four men each on nine points — one more than Three Men's Morris, and just enough that only a single point stays empty once everyone's down.

  • Four pieces a side instead of three — only one point stays empty after placing
  • A row formed while still placing doesn't win outright — we had to compute why that matters
  • Against the computer, a friend online, or two players on one device
Play Achi
Picaria — screenshot of the browser gameBoard Game
Three in a Row2 Players

Picaria

Thirteen points, not the usual nine — four extra points sit halfway between each corner and the centre, splitting every long diagonal into two short lines instead of one.

  • A genuine thirteen-point board — not a repaint of the same nine-point grid every other game like it uses
  • The centre connects to all eight neighbours — every row, column and short diagonal passes through it
  • Against the computer, a friend online, or two players on one device
Play Picaria